Recycled paper or plastic?

bioplastic PapcornOur in-house environmental expert, Priyadharshini poses the million dollar question – should we recycle paper or plastic? She also suggests a better alternative for both! The other day, I dropped in at a café to have a cup of coffee. As I sipped my hot coffee, my eyes caught to a quote “Avoid plastics, Use paper bags”.

Most of us might have come across such environmental awareness quotes in public places, but I wondered have we ever given a second thought what lies behind that sentence?

In today’s modern world, the importance of environment is sought but uncared for. We blindly follow the alternatives for lesser impact on the environment. One such example is the usage of paper bags for plastic bags. Usage of plastic (polythene) carry bags has become inevitable. So paper bags have been suggested as an alternative. The word “paper” suggests that the paper bag is easily recyclable and that it is not as bad as plastic since it is biodegradable.

However, most paper cups and bags are coated with a plastic resin (i.e., polyethylene) for durability and convenience, therefore making both their composting and recycling difficult and raising the specter of carcinogenic chemical leaching. Depending on the forestry practices (and whether they are sustainably produced or not) paper bag production results in loss of trees, ecological degradation and a reduction in the planet’s carbon absorption capacity. In our world of shrinking forests and growing landfill, continued use of the paper bag is both dangerous and unsustainable.

When we compare the complete lifecycle analysis of paper or plastic bag, that is the ‘cradle to grave’ process which includes the impacts caused by a product right from its raw material extraction to its disposal, then we can clearly say which one is more sustainable. The sustainability of paper and plastic can be compared over their lifecycle, covering both energy and water footprints.

Bio-plastic fruit containers
Bio-plastic fruit containers

Paper is produced from either tree barks or recycled paper. The production of paper consumes lots of water and beaching chemicals which produce toxic effluents harmful to the environment. On the other hand, the transportation of paper from the industry to consumer also consumes lots of fuel, creating a carbon footprint. In terms of recycling, paper can be only recycled 2-3 times due to its inflexibility and strength, and it again requires large amount of water for the process. Paper production consumes 935 times more water compared to plastic.

On the contrary, plastic is derived from crude oil residues and their carbon footprint for both the production and transportation is much lesser when compared to paper. The recycling of plastic is flexible and it can be done 5-10 times. So, in this background, we can now decide between paper and plastic based on our convenience and the recyclable capacity before its final disposal. Thankfully, advanced technology has brought in latest innovation which presents us a clever way out of the present problem.

Recycled Paper Or Plastic Infographic

Bio-plastics are derived from corn, sugarcane and other renewable biomass resources. These biodegradable thermoplastic material made from Polylactic Acid polymer are very much similar to the regular Polythene material. Corn-based plastic bags in particular have been gaining popularity in the West. Due to their natural origin and biodegradability characteristics, Bio-plastics can be converted into high-quality compost. Admittedly, there is much lesser carbon footprint from reusable Bio-plastic bags during their production and also from rinsing in hot water.

In India, are few companies have begun commercial production of Bio-plastics. Earthsoul India and Ravi Industries in Maharashtra, Harita NTI Ltd and Biotec Bags in Tamilnadu have been the pioneers in Bio-plastics. Now let’s hope consumer goods companies come forward to choose Bio-plastics and considerably reduce their carbon footprint and make their products more sustainable.

Text – Priyadharshini.B

- Factfile –
http://en.european-bioplastics.org/bioplastics/

http://www.chillibreeze.com/articles/ACaseforDegradablePlastic.asp

http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/08_26/b4090044437763.htm

http://india.carbon-outlook.com/content/which-more-sustainable-paper-or-plastic

http://hawaiifreepress.com/main/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/1197/Paper-vs-Plastic-An-environmental-comparison.aspx

Posted in: Eco-Ideaz
Priyadharshini

About the Author:

Dream, Desire, Deserve.....Wish to reach the stars but if I reach not atleast, I will fly. .... Waves are my inspiration – they fall yet they rise! Destined to spell a magic to naturalize the world green! Travelling, exploring nature and culture are my passions. Want to dive deep into the sea and fly high in the skies but all confined to my world of imaginations. At present, I am a Student of Environmental Engineering and Management at Pondicherry University. I have put my tenderfoot towards writing. Wish to serve nature and create a better sustainable earth for future generation through the power of pen! Destined to my journey for making cleaner and safer Environment. Go to Priyadharshini B's personal site...

Discuss this post on Facebook

4 Comments on "Recycled paper or plastic?"

Trackback | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Cholo says:

    Nice post.Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! I've been looking for books of this nature for a way too long. I'm just glad that I found yours. Looking forward for your next post. Thanks :)

    Cholo
    http://www.0y7.net

  2. N.N.Veer says:

    Your colourful display ( good effort for marketing ) is wrong & deceiving.
    I wish you gather courage to mention comparative price data for any specific date & location and be prepared to substantiate them through the mobile nos.of it's source.
    100% Marks for your colourful crafting. Hoping to receive your factual data soon.
    N.N.Veer

  3. Andrew Pelt says:

    I got myself a set of the flat Gascans, and from the very first time I used it the knobs make high decibel crushing disturbance and vinyl flakes take a flight onto the the len’s.

Post a Comment